Courts and contempt powers in India: The case of Jolly LLB-2

Vrinda Bhandari - 4th April 2017

Although the Legislature and the Executive are the subject of regular political satire in India, last month the courts showed that contempt powers can be used to create a hitherto-unknown zone of immunity around the judiciary and legal profession in India. The case of Jolly LLB-2 The case involved the movie “Jolly LLB-2”. Here, a […]

Read full article »

France Risks Violating the Right to Freedom of Expression with New Abortion Law Proposals

Laurence Wilkinson - 17th March 2017

France is set to introduce a controversial new law which criminalizes the online ‘obstruction’ of abortion. The legislation will extend existing provisions that have made it a criminal offence in France to physically intimidate or pressure a woman with a view to stopping her from having an abortion. The original law was intended to prevent […]

Read full article »

What’s in a name? The criminal implications of pleasantries

Rory Kelly - 9th February 2017

In September a new batch of research assistants started at the Law Commission in London. Having collected them from reception, I brought them over to meet the rest of the criminal law team, and said, ‘Everybody, this is K and S, they’re new.’ At first glance, this appears to be a relatively innocuous encounter. However, […]

Read full article »

Access to information in order to speak freely: Is this a right under the European Convention?

Lucy Maxwell - 19th January 2017

If access to government information is “necessary” for you to investigate and communicate about matters of “obvious public interest”, you may have a right to that information, according to the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights.  In a much-anticipated judgment, the Grand Chamber has found that the right to freedom of expression […]

Read full article »

Right of Access to Information: An Empowering Tool for the Enjoyment of Other Human Rights in Argentina

Karina Banfi - 25th November 2016

Argentina has taken a big step towards government transparency and accountability by enacting, on September 29th 2016, its very own Law on Right of Access to Information. This long-awaited law regulates the right of access to information, which includes the freedom to seek, receive and re-use information held not only by public authorities from the executive branch, […]

Read full article »

Drone Journalism and Regulatory Challenges in India

Mohd Owais Farooqui - 7th October 2016

Drones can be used for journalism, alongside many other civilian purposes. Ethical considerations such as safety and privacy are likely to arise in the context of drone journalism. This raises pertinent questions of whether journalists can use drones at all and whether capturing pictures in public places by drones is permissible under Indian law. Drone […]

Read full article »

PJS v News Group Newspapers: Threesomes! Privacy! Social Media!

Claire Overman and Andrew Wheelhouse - 8th September 2016

On 19 May 2016, the UK Supreme Court handed down judgment in PJS v News Group Newspapers Limited. This decision concerned the proposed publication of details concerning the extramarital activities of PJS, an individual in the entertainment industry married to a well-known celebrity. News Group Newspapers (“NGN”) had notified PJS that it proposed to publish […]

Read full article »

Online Speech in Hungary before the Strasbourg Court: Freeing the Low

Tamas Szigeti - 16th March 2016

The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) in MTE and v Hungary (“MTE/Index”) issued a decision protecting free speech in the form of user-generated online comments. In particular, the judges courageously confronted complicated questions of online speech instead of taking refuge in the complacent argument of censoring any bad speech. MTE/Index concerned two offensive […]

Read full article »

A New Regime for Data Protection in Europe

Claire Overman and Andrew Wheelhouse - 14th March 2016

Almost four years after its initial proposal in January 2012, the finalised text of the General Data Protection Regulation (the Regulation) was agreed in December 2015. It is anticipated to enter into force in January 2018, bringing with it some major changes to the current European data protection regime. One such change is in the […]

Read full article »

Endangering Democracy: Concerns Over Raising Surveillance in China

Sakshi Aravind - 15th February 2016

Control over cyber space and information, particularly citizens’ data, has defined modern strategies of combating terrorism through technologies. Justifications provided for extensive surveillance legislation that may impinge civil liberties have been riveted on states’ responsibility to adopt counter-terrorism mechanisms. This has resulted in deeply problematic restraints on media freedom and free speech. One such piece […]

Read full article »

Journalism, Detention and Anti-Terrorism Powers

Andrew Wheelhouse and Claire Overman - 3rd February 2016

Few would dispute that journalistic sources and material deserve special legal protection in a liberal democracy. But few would suggest that this protection should confer a licence to damage national security. Where should the balance be struck? This was the question confronting the English Court of Appeal in R (Miranda) v SSHD and another [2016] […]

Read full article »

The Right to be Forgotten: Grappling with Practicalities (Part 2)

Claire Overman and Andrew Wheelhouse - 21st January 2016

In the last post we charted the development of the regulatory environment following the advent of the so-called ‘right to be forgotten’ (RTBF) following the landmark Costeja judgment. In this post we consider some of the practical problems that the judgment has generated. What is the required geographical extent of de-listing? Can the right be implemented […]

Read full article »