Prisoners’ Voting Rights: The Constitutional and Policy Case for Compliance with the Judgment of the Strasbourg Court-Sir Jeffrey Jowell QC (UCL)

by | Aug 15, 2016

The European Court of Human Rights, in the case of Hirst, has held that the UK’s blanket ban on prisoners’ voting offends Convention rights.  The previous Prime Minister said that prisoners voting makes him ‘physically sick’ and the House of Commons has passed a resolution in effect encouraging defiance of Strasbourg’s ruling.

Apart from the question of the UK’s obligation in international law to implement the judgments of the Strasbourg Court, and the practical implications of non-compliance, does the ban on prisoners’ voting violate purely domestic constitutional principles?

Three such principles will be discussed:

  • The presumption of liberty;
  • The principle of equality, and
  • Parliamentary sovereignty.

Irrespective of those principles, could the ban be justified as necessary and proportionate in a democratic society? Does it fulfil the accepted aims of penal policy or, on the contrary, does it not speak to those aims or indeed subvert them (in particular, the aim of rehabilitation)?

img_20161115_130558 img_20161115_130408 img_20161115_131233-1

A recording of the event can be found here.

Share this:

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Related Content

IACL Virtual Global Roundtable: ‘Democracy 2020’

IACL Virtual Global Roundtable: ‘Democracy 2020’

  On 18-26 November the International Association of Constitutional Law (IACL) Global Roundtable ‘Democracy ...
New Publication: Socio-Economic Rights and Constitutional Law

New Publication: Socio-Economic Rights and Constitutional Law

Socio-Economic Rights and Constitutional Law (eds) Sandra Fredman, Director of the OxHRH and Meghan Campbell, ...
Centre for Law and Policy Research (India): Rights in Review 2015

Centre for Law and Policy Research (India): Rights in Review 2015

The Centre for Law and Policy, based in Bangalore, India, has released a fascinating report analyzing the human ...