Referrals to the Grand Chamber of the European Court of Human Rights: What Questions are Serious Enough?-Prof Fiona de Londras (Durham)

by | Jan 22, 2015

Decisions of a chamber of the European Court of Human Rights can be referred by either party for reconsideration by the Grand Chamber. These referral applications are then decided upon by a panel of five judges, which decides whether they raise sufficiently ‘serious’ questions for the Grand Chamber to be convened. The process and principles by which the panel makes this decision are, however, somewhat opaque and rates of success in such referrals are very low. This paper builds on original analysis of referral patterns and interviews with judges of the European Court of Human Rights to assess what constitutes ‘seriousness’ in this context. The paper argues that this analysis suggests that seriousness in this context is best understood by reference to a developing constitutionalist identity on the part of the Grand Chamber, rather than to the perceived seriousness of an alleged rights violation per se, thus reinforcing the growing characterization of the Court as a constitutionalist tribunal for Europe.

This event is co-hosted with the Oxford Martin School, Human Rights for Future Generations Programme.

 

Here is the audio podcast from this event:

HR_logo

 

 

 

 

Share this:

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Related Content

OxHRH Seminars Available Online!

OxHRH Seminars Available Online!

During the end of year break, do check out the recordings from the OxHRH Seminars: The Historical Roots of the ...
Professor Sandra Fredman Gives Evidence to the Women and Equalities Commission

Professor Sandra Fredman Gives Evidence to the Women and Equalities Commission

On Wednesday 16 November 2016, OxHRH Director, Professor Sandra Fredman along with Dr Panos Kapotas (University of ...
Call for Papers for the OxHRH Graduate Research Student Workshop 2021

Call for Papers for the OxHRH Graduate Research Student Workshop 2021

  Venue: Zoom Date: Wednesday 26 and Thursday 27 May 2021 Time: 2-4pm The Oxford Human Rights Hub is ...