Human Rights-Based Migrant Integration Policy: Lessons from Ireland – Part I
The issue of migrant integration has become a key policy area for many European countries, as well as the European Union (“EU”) level. “Integration” is a notoriously difficult idea to pin down, and both the meaning and measurement of integration remain controversial. Some commentators view the idea as inherently negative and as representing a rejection of diversity by migrant receiving societies. Integration is sometimes associated with assimilation, discrimination and a retreat from multiculturalism. One important illustration of this restrictive turn is the use of integration “tests” by many European states as a mandatory condition for access to family reunification and citizenship rights, for example. At the same time, however, competing narratives of integration centred on holistic, two-way paradigms of social inclusion continue to emerge from NGOs, international organisations and academics.
The case for a human rights-based approach
It is clear that, in practice, integration measures can result in the primary responsibility for integration being shifted away from the state and on to migrant individuals and communities. Given this, we argue that current measurements of integration such as the Zaragoza indicators developed by the EU, which focus primarily on outcomes, are insufficient for the purposes of understanding how to develop effective and participatory integration policies. They do not track progress towards these outcomes, and they do not adequately identify the objectives which should inform state policy on integration. As a consequence, they miss opportunities for intervention directed at “full participation and integration of migrants”.
We argue that integration must be considered a long-term process, and that the normative goal of this process should be the full realisation of the human rights of migrants and their inclusion as equal members of society. Moreover, in the Irish context, public bodies are now required to apply a human rights and equality lens to their integration policies and practices under the general public sector duty laid down in the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission Act 2014. This is similar to the public sector equality duty under the Equality Act 2010 in the UK.
Supporting human rights-based integration policy development by public bodies
With all of this in mind, public sector bodies should be supported in developing integration policies which are fully consistent with the highest international human rights standards. Our project (funded by the Irish Human Rights and Equality Commission) has devised a model of best practice for integration policy based on international human rights law standards, against which we can assess public sector integration policy-making.
What does a human rights-based model of integration look like?
Our human rights model uses as its foundation the concept of integration under construction by the UN treaty bodies established under the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; and the International Covenant for the Elimination of all forms of Racial Discrimination. This concept has been identified primarily through an analysis of these bodies’ concluding observations on periodic state reports up to December 2017.
The common thread in the work of the three bodies which we have studied is the insistence on the protection of the human rights of migrants and the creation of equal opportunities through rights protection. There is also a strong emphasis on putting in place policies which are actually effective in their aim to include migrants as equal members of society. The human rights approach is based on individual equality, interculturalism, and state responsibility for social inclusion; setting it apart from other initiatives and models such as the EU’s Common Basic Principles. Drawing on the approach of the human rights treaty bodies, we have found that the basic elements of a human rights-based approach to integration are:
- A commitment to the State’s positive duty to eliminate discrimination.
- The implementation of practical measures to ensure equality of opportunity in respect of civil, political, social and economic rights, for all people resident in the State.
- The active promotion of tolerance and respect for cultural and linguistic diversity.
- A rejection of the ideas of (i) cultural assimilation; (ii) a one-sided notion of integration which places the onus of ‘integration’ primarily on the individual; and (iii) integration ‘testing’ of individuals.
Audit and review of public sector integration policies in Ireland
Having developed a model of best practice for integration policy, based on human rights and equality principles, the next stages of our project conducted an audit and human rights review of the integration policies of public bodies in Ireland. We will highlight some of the results of this audit and review in the second part of this post, which will appear on the blog in the coming weeks. These results will also appear in our project report, which was published today, 27 November 2017.