• Home
  • About us
  • People
  • Blog
  • News
  • Video
  • Webinars
  • Seminars
  • Podcasts
  • Publications
    • Journal Articles
    • Working Papers
    • OxHRH Annual Report
    • Books & Chapters
    • U of OxHRH Journal
  • Events
  • Journal
  • GDPR Compliance
  • Home
  • Home OHRH
  • Media
  • Search
  • Test page
  • Publications
  • About us
  • News
  • A big page
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
  • Site Map
  • Legal
  • Event archive
  • Blog
    • Comments Policy
    • Contribute to the Blog
  • Events
  • Journal
  • People
  • publications test
  • Publications New
    • Inner Publications Landing
  • #16346 (no title)
Oxford Human Rights Hub logo
  • Home
  • About us
  • People
  • Blog
  • News
  • Media
  • Events
  • Publications
  • Journal

‘But a Small Price to Pay’ – Degradation of Rights in Childbirth During COVID-19

Daniela Drandic and Fleurvan Leeuwen - 8th April 2020
OxHRH
Gender Equality
Maternity Ward birth room

‘No visitors. Induced labor. Converted delivery wards. Tens of thousands of women across the country are giving birth in unprecedented circumstances.’ Maternal healthcare is changing around the world in response to COVID-19. Many of these measures intended to curb the pandemic are at tension with a range of women’s rights in childbirth and deserve close scrutiny.

Problems in maternal healthcare during COVID-19

Different methods are being used to tackle the pandemic around the world. The responses show that, despite current evidence and WHO guidelines, in a crisis, structural violations of women’s rights may quickly become the norm, justified as necessary to contain the epidemic. Some of these include:

  • Women being denied the right to a companion during labour and birth, as well as visitors;
  • Women increasingly being subjected to (forced) inductions and caesarean sections with no obstetric indication;
  • Women being separated from their infants;
  • Maternity services de-prioritised with regards to adequate staffing, personal protective equipment for staff and other resources;
  • Closing of community and out of hospital maternity services (birth centres and home birth);
  • Decades-long practices of centralising maternity care in hospitals resulting in a situation where healthy women must give birth in institutions also caring for COVID-19 patients and raise their own risk of infection.

Women’s rights in childbirth

Many of these practices may amount to violence against women and are at tension with a range of rights, including the right to be free from torture, inhuman and degrading treatment, the right to private life and the right to non-discrimination.

Although temporary restrictions to certain rights and freedoms are allowed under international human rights law it is essential that these measures have a legal basis, are proportionate, necessary and non-discriminatory and are designed to minimise interference with human rights. Many of the measures that are being adopted in maternal healthcare settings do not live up to these requirements. Besides the fact that little or no evidence has been provided for the effectiveness of these measures (and the WHO has advised against them), a number of other countries have shown that less invasive responses are possible. The Netherlands, for example, has converted hotels near obstetric units into popup birth centres, and in New Zealand women who are asymptomatic are still able to choose their place of birth. In France, women can have a birth companion who is asymptomatic and whose movement within facilities is restricted to lower the chances for disease transmission.

Systemic discrimination

The UN Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women (UN SR-VAW) recognises that mistreatment and violence against women during childbirth occurs in the wider context of structural inequality, discrimination and patriarchy. Harmful gender stereotypes in the reproductive health context, ideas about ‘women’s natural role in society and motherhood’ and the belief that childbirth is an event that requires suffering on the part of the woman are being used to limit autonomy and agency. These gendered beliefs, coupled with the power imbalance that exists between healthcare providers and pregnant women (particularly apparent in instances in which providers abuse the doctrine of medical necessity in order to justify mistreatment and abuse during childbirth) require us to be highly critical of harmful short-term remedies in the context of maternal healthcare and make it necessary to search for more proportional alternatives.

Final remarks

The COVID-19 pandemic requires a swift global response to contain the virus’ spread and protect the life and health of others. But this does not mean that states can use any means to achieve this. UN human rights experts have called upon states to maintain a human rights-based approach to regulating the COVID-19 outbreak and have held that the pandemic should not be used as an excuse to target the rights of particular groups, minorities or individuals, nor should it be used as cover for repressive action under the guise of protecting health.

We should be wary of any use of the pandemic to institutionalise harmful practices in maternal healthcare and ensure that hardwon rights in childbirth are not needlessly overrun.

Author profile

Daniela Drandić is a maternal rights advocate at the Croatian NGO Roda - Parents in Action. She is an M.Sc. student at the University of Dundee and board member of Human Rights in Childbirth.

Dr. Fleur van Leeuwen, LL.M. is a lecturer in law at Boğaziçi University, department of Political Science and International Relations, in Istanbul, Turkey and an affiliated researcher at Atria - Institute on Gender Equality and Women’s history in Amsterdam, the Netherlands. She is the managing editor of the peer reviewed Tijdschrift voor Genderstudies (Journal of Gender Studies). Her work can be found on fleurvanleeuwen.academia.edu.

Citations

Daniela Drandić and Dr. Fleur van Leeuwen, “‘But a Small Price to Pay’ – Degradation of Rights in Childbirth During COVID-19”, (OxHRH Blog, April 2020), <http://ohrh.law.ox.ac.uk/but-a-small-price-to-pay-degradation-of-rights-in-childbirth-during-covid-19/>, [Date of access].

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related blog posts

Responding to Ireland’s Mother and Baby Homes Commission Report
The Tune Goes On: Appointments to Tribunals Must Adhere to The Two-Thirds Gender Rule
Can trans children consent to puberty blocking drugs? The High Court of England and Wales doubts it.

Related events

Invitation to the conference “Women’s Human Rights in the Twenty-First Century”, European Court of Human Rights, 14 February 2020
External

Related news

OxHRH Special Blog Series: Celebrating the Global Women’s Suffrage Movement

Contact Us

oxfordhumanrightshub@law.ox.ac.uk

Oxford Human Rights Hub
The Faculty of Law, University of Oxford,
St Cross Building,
St Cross Road,
Oxford OX1 3UL

© 2021 Oxford Human Rights Hub | Site by One


Sign up for the OHRH Newsletter

Your email address*:

New email sign up
reCAPTCHA
* Find out how we use your data