In its recent judgment in X v. Georgia, the European Court of Human Rights (the Court) considered whether a State complies with its positive obligations under Articles 3 (prohibition of torture) and 8 (right to respect for private and family life) of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) where it maintains a formally adequate legal framework but fails to apply it effectively in practice. This case reveals that formal compliance with obligations is insufficient when the response to the investigation into allegation of sexual abuse of a minor by her stepfather by the domestic authorities is characterised by a lack of action, a procedural exclusion and possible retraumatisation of the victim.
The victim, a minor who alleged she had been sexually assaulted by her stepfather between May and July 2019, revealed the events in 2021, leading to the immediate opening of a criminal investigation. This investigation uncovered messages in which she allegedly described the assaults. However, despite this evidence, the investigation “remained at a standstill between 2021 and 2026, for more than five years, without any further action being taken.” Chiefly, throughout this period, the applicant was never granted victim status, which limited her ability to fully participate in the proceedings.
Although the Court affirmed the positive obligation of the State to conduct an investigation of the sexual violence allegations as soon as possible, it was not willing to place the burden of proof to disprove the appearance of discriminatory treatment on the State. Instead, it adopted an excessively formalistic approach by requiring the applicant to produce her own evidence to support her complaint under Article 14 (prohibition of discrimination).
The effectiveness of institutional practice
First, the Court confirmed an analysis of Articles 3 and 8 of the Convention focused on the effectiveness of institutional practices and emphasises that the protection of Convention rights does not depend on the formal existence of rules. This judgment aligns with two lines of case law. On the one hand, as previously noted in X v. CYPRUS, the Court has emphasized that States must not only enact laws prohibiting sexual violence but also ensure their effective and impartial application. On the other hand—given that authorities are often ill-prepared to handle cases involving sexual crimes—the judgment highlights the structural risks of victim-blaming, thereby situating itself within the anti-stereotyping approach that the Court has developed for cases of sexual violence. The mere existence of rules is insufficient; there must also be effective implementation of those rules by the authorities responsible for conducting investigations.
The requirement of promptness
In accordance with Articles 3 and 8 of the ECHR, the requirement for promptness in criminal investigations is an essential element of the State’s procedural obligations, particularly in cases involving minors.
“Special diligence” is required, given the victim’s vulnerability (M.C. v. BULGARIA) and the risk of re-traumatization. In this regard, the judgment is consistent with established case law (X v. CYPRUS, §123), highlighting that an investigation which exposes a victim to further trauma cannot satisfy the requirements of Articles 3 and 8. Indeed, procedural obligations encompass not only the duty to investigate, but also the obligation to conduct such investigations in a manner that respects the dignity and physical integrity of the victims.
In S.Z. v. BULGARIA (§47), the Court emphasized that an effective investigation—given that the passage of time risks compromising the availability and reliability of evidence—must enable the facts to be established and evidence to be gathered without delay. Institutional negligence may become entrenched due to persistent inertia during investigations, leading to a form of secondary victimization (P.M. v. Bulgaria, §64-65). Furthermore, the alleged perpetrator may also benefit from promptness, as their right to a fair trial could be hindered by unreasonable delays—for instance, in the collection of evidence.
To conclude compliance with Articles 3 and 8 requires not only that States criminalise sexual assault, but also that they investigate these allegations diligently, sensitively, and with a genuine commitment to establishing the truth. The gap between the law and its application remains a significant challenge for the Court’s jurisprudence on sexual violence, a challenge which cannot be met solely by legislative reform but by increased attention paid to the procedural situation of victims, especially when they are vulnerable.





0 Comments