In July, my College at Oxford, Somerville, organized a student delegation impacted by the United Kingdom (UK)’s student visa ban to attend a Royal Courts of Justice hearing. As a woman from Afghanistan, I sought to testify there, as the ban profoundly affects Afghan students. For Afghan women and girls, who have already surmounted formidable Taliban restrictions to pursue higher education, the UK ban imposes yet another barrier to their education.
What does it mean to live under Taliban rule as women and girls? In a nutshell, it means disenfranchisement from most human rights and dignity solely based on the grounds of gender. The girls are barred from secondary education, university, and private medical training institutions, restricted from most employment, and are prohibited from free movement and traveling over 72 kilometers without a legal male guardian (mahram). They cannot access judicial remedies, legal protections, or health services independently. These interconnected violations and deprivations that the U.N. Special Rapporteur on Afghanistan, Richard Bennett, in his report to the Human Rights Council 46 session, formally described as “a system of discrimination, segregation, disrespect for human dignity, and exclusion,” reflect the Taliban’s institutional subjugation of Afghan women and girls.
The ICJ-CEDAW, and the role of the UK
What is happening in Afghanistan is an unprecedented scale of violation of the 1979 Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW). The scale that has led the International Criminal Court to issue arrest warrants for the four Taliban leaders for persecution on gender grounds as crimes against humanity, a crime codified in Article 7(1)(h) of the Rome Statute. The conduct in question involves intentionally attacking a specific population, and in the case of Afghanistan, the targets are the Afghan women and girls.
Given that domestic avenues to justice are entirely unavailable under Taliban rule, international legal and non-legal mechanisms are vital for accountability. That is why the announcement by four countries, i.e., Australia, Canada, Germany, and the Netherlands, of their intention to hold the Taliban accountable for their grave violations of the CEDAW Convention (the ICJ-CEDAW initiative) is a unique path. Even though the violations are not happening in their territories or impacting the women and girls living under their jurisdiction. CEDAW, like other international conventions, is owed erga omnes partes to all States Parties to the Convention, meaning States share an interest in upholding the obligations of other States Parties to the Convention. This principle was key in The Gambia v Myanmar, concerning the alleged violations of the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide. The ICJ accepted jurisdiction despite Myanmar contending that The Gambia lacked direct territorial standing, as the erga omnes partes principle provides the avenue through which States maintain a common interest in preventing violations of the Conventions.
The international response must reflect the full breadth of the crisis in Afghanistan. Taliban edicts and decrees extend far beyond educational bans and work restrictions; the Taliban’s developed architecture systematically dismantles women’s participation in public and professional life and future chances of involvement in the country. These restrictions violate multiple international legal instruments, e.g., CEDAW, the International Labour Organization (ILO) convention that safeguards the right to work, and the Convention on the Political Rights of Women. The UK can initiate additional legal proceedings under these conventions, including with countries from the Global South, to address violations against women’s rights in Afghanistan.
The UK has demonstrated a commitment to advancing gender equality and human rights globally, and it has explicitly supported the ICJ-CEDAW initiative. The UK can use its diplomatic engagement with the four initiating states to encourage movement from negotiation to arbitration if negotiations fail to yield a result. As we enter the fifth year of the Taliban’s return, the situation on the ground is worsening. However, there is significant tension between the UK’s foreign policy stance and the impact of its domestic immigration policy on Afghan women. To show genuine support for human rights and women’s rights in Afghanistan, the UK government must exempt Afghan female students from visa restrictions and bans and expand dedicated university scholarships to ensure the right to education is protected, at least in the crucial area where Britain has direct leverage.






0 Comments