When the Executioner Becomes the Broadcaster: Streaming the Fort Hood Firing Squad

by | Nov 14, 2026

author profile picture

About Federico Domenico Barilla

Federico Domenico Barilla is a lawyer and doctoral researcher at the University of Vienna’s Institute for Canon Law and the Law of Religion and he graduated in Law at LUISS "Guido Carli". His research focuses on canon law, international humanitarian law, religious diplomacy, the Holy See, the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, human rights, religious freedom, political philosophy and state theory. Federico Domenico Barilla est avocat et doctorant à l'Institut de droit canonique et de droit des religions de l'Université de Vienne ; il est diplômé en droit de l'Université LUISS « Guido Carli ». Ses recherches portent sur le droit canonique, le droit international humanitaire, la diplomatie religieuse, le Saint-Siège, l'Ordre souverain de Malte, les droits de l'homme, la liberté religieuse, la philosophie politique et la théorie de l'État.

The Pentagon has announced that it will execute Nidal Hasan, the Army major convicted of the 2009 Fort Hood shooting, by firing squad on 3 December and streamed live. The announcement is legally unprecedented. It is the first United States military execution in over sixty-five years and the first by firing squad since the Second World War. The UN human rights office responded within a day: broadcasting an execution in real time amounts to a public executionand breaches the absolute prohibition of torture. Broadcasting a killing does not make it just: it only proves that the state, having failed to deter anything, now sells cruelty as content, and that an execution staged for a live audience is not justice but spectacle.

10 U.S.C. § 857(a)(3), Uniform Code of Military Justice Article 57(a)(3), provides that a military death sentence “may not be executed until approved by the President.” President Trump approved Hasan’s sentence on 2 October 2026; on 6 October the Acting Secretary of the Army directed that it be carried out by firing squad. The method rests on Army Regulation 190-55, which previously prescribed lethal injection and now names no fixed method.

No court has ever recognised a right to transmit such an event. In the civilian federal system the law prohibits it outright: 28 C.F.R. § 26.4(f) provides that “No photographic or other visual or audio recording of the execution shall be permitted,” a rule the government defended in Entertainment Network, Inc v. Lappin (2001) as guarding against the “sensationalizing” of executions, prison order, and the privacy of the condemned. Military regulation does not replicate the ban; that gap is what the Pentagon’s plan occupies.

The First Amendment case law points the same way. In Holden v. Minnesota (1890), the US Supreme Court upheld a statute confining executions within jail walls and excluding reporters entirely. In Garrett v. Estelle (1977), the Fifth Circuit held that the news-gathering right “does not extend to matters not accessible to the public generally, such as filming of executions.” In California First Amendment Coalition v. Calderon (1998), the Ninth Circuit held that restrictions on witness viewing of executions do not violate the First Amendment, stressing that the press holds no greater right of access than the public. In Entertainment Network v. Lappin, the district court refused to allow the webcast of Timothy McVeigh’s execution, the first federal one since 1963; only a closed-circuit feed for victims’ families was approved.

Every court to reach the question has refused to find any right to broadcast an execution. On 3 December the state plans to supply that transmission itself.

International law is no different. The ECOSOC Safeguards of 1984 require in safeguard 9 that executions be carried out so as to “inflict the minimum possible suffering”; a staged, filmed, and distributed death is hard to reconcile with that benchmark. In Europe, abolition closed the question: Protocol No. 6 to the European Convention on Human Rights abolished the death penalty in peacetime, Protocol No. 13 extended abolition to all circumstances, and abolition is a condition of Council of Europe membership.

The doctrinal roots are older than the case law. Cesare Beccaria warned in Dei delitti e delle pene (1764) that a penal death “becomes a spectacle”, producing compassion and indignation in spectators rather than the salutary terror the law intends. Felice Barilla, a priest imprisoned in the Bourbon purge of 1851, pressed the same logic in his La pena di morte (2nd ed., Naples, Perrotti, 1863): a punishment that cannot correct, and that teaches cruelty by example, fails the moral test the state invokes for it. The 1939 decree ending public executions in France completed a century of reform in one direction.

If the broadcast proceeds, the United States will invert its settled law. The regulation its lawyers have defended calls broadcasting an execution a form of sensationalism; the executive branch would thus be the sensationalist. Lawful channels for witnessing exist already such as witness pools and closed-circuit transmission for victims’ families. A global live feed serves none of the interests the law recognises.

The deeper point stands beyond the broadcast: no method of execution is reconcilable with human dignity, and the punishment itself should not exist. Every staged death is a lesson in cruelty, taught by the state.

Share this:

Related Content

0 Comments

Submit a Comment